WB00825_2.GIF (134 bytes) Promiscuity

Given that most learners do have sex, it becomes important to reduce promiscuous sexual behaviour. Over 80% of learners knew that avoiding promiscuity is one way of reducing the risk of contracting an STD, with somewhat more learners at Sapler schools knowing this.

Can you get an STD if you and your boyfriend/girlfriend are healthy and stay faithful?
N=432 Other Sapler
Yes 11 9.1
No 82 87
Don't know 7.0 4
chisq=2.; df=2; p=.359

A similar high proportion realised that both partners have to be faithful.

Can you get an STD if are faithful but your boyfriend/girlfriend is not faithful?
N=430 Other Sapler
Yes 85 86
No 9.3 8.1
Don't know 5.4 5.8
chisq=.2123; df=2; p=.899

Ninety four percent of learners at Sapler schools and 90% of learners at other schools thought it wrong for boys to be promiscuous. Promiscuity is generally considered a key risk behaviour and it is therefore encouraging that it is rejected by the overwhelming majority of learners (at least at the level of rhetoric).

It's OK if a boy has sex with lots of girls
N=394 Other % Sapler %
Strongly 3.4 .6
Agree 2.5 3.8
Not sure 3.8 1.9
Disagree 20 13
Strongly 70 81
chisq=9.; df=4; p=.065

Somewhat more learners (96%) at both schools rejected promiscuity for girls than for boys. This double-standard was most prominent at non-Sapler schools, where 6% more learners rejected promiscuity for girls than for boys.

It's OK if a girl has sex with lots of boys
N=394 Other Sapler
Strongly 1.7 0
Agree .4 1.3
Not sure 1.3 2.5
Disagree 19 13
Strongly 77 83
chisq=7.; df=4; p=118

Interestingly, girls did not subscribe to the double standard, with 94% rejecting both male and female promiscuity. However only 77% of boys rejected male promiscuity as opposed to 92% who rejected female promiscuity. The same pattern obtained for learners at Sapler schools as at other schools.

It's OK if a boy has sex with lots of girls (values for Sapler schools in brackets)
N=394 (176) Girls Boys
Strongly 1.9 (1.9) 9.9 (6.8)
  1.1 (0) 6.8 (8.2)
Not sure 3.3 (3.9) 6.2 (2.7)
Disagree 18 (14) 20 (21)
Strongly 76 (81) 57 (62)
chisq=30.88; df=4; p=000 (chisq=14.58 df=4; p=.006)
It's OK for a girl has sex with lots of boys (values for Sapler schools in brackets)
N=394 Other Sapler
Strongly 1.5 (0) 1.9 (1.4)
Agree 1.9 (2.9) 2.5 (1.4)
Not sure 2.6 (1.9) 3.1 (4.1)
Disagree 17 (15) 22 (22)
Strongly 77 (81) 70 (71)
chisq=2.622; df=4; p=.622 (chisq=4.364; df=4; p=.360)

Thus although promiscuity is overwhelmingly rejected by learners, particularly by learners at Sapler schools, boys’ attitude towards male promiscuity remains a problem with between one in four and one in five boys endorsing it. As this kind of bravado is very much part of male culture in South Africa and elsewhere, it is unlikely to be easily changed and presents a particular challenge for institutions such as Sapler.

Another question tapping support for promiscuity (having more than one partner at a time) elicited similar strong rejection coupled with greater tolerance for boys’ promiscuous behaviour.

It's OK for a girl to have more than one boyfriend at a time
N=389 Other Sapler
Strongly 3.4 3.2
Agree 3.8 1.9
Not sure 3.0 4.5
Disagree 22 19
Strongly 68 71
chisq=2.; df=4; p=.692
It's Ok for a boy to have more than one girlfriend at a time
N=388 Other Sapler
Strongly 4.3 3.9
Agree 7.3 3.2
Not sure 4.7 5.8
Disagree 25 20
Strongly 59 67
chisq=5.; df=4; p=.291

Given the rhetorical rejection of promiscuity, it is striking that 30% and more of learners indicated that they indeed do have more than one girlfriend or boyfriend. 

It is possible that again there may have been an element of male bravura in these responses (over 40% of boys claimed to have multiple sexual partners), but they are nevertheless in sharp contrast to the almost blanket rejection of the principle of promiscuity.

Do you have more than one boyfriend/girlfriend that you have sex with? (figures for boys only in brackets)
N-312 (120) Other Sapler
Yes 30 (41) 34 (45)
No 70 (59) 66 (55)
chisq=.724; df=1; p=.395 (chisq=.197; df=1; p=.657)

Another indication of promiscuity is the number of sexual encounters during the year and the total number of sexual partners of each learner. 

Unfortunately, these appear to have been difficult questions for learners to answer, with numerous implausible answers provided, such as over 200 sexual partners or many sexual encounters but no sexual partners. 

After the more unlikely answers were discarded, the number of sexual encounters this year was found to range from 0 to 70 with an average of 9 for learners at Sapler schools and 7.6 at other schools. 

Number of sexual partners ranged from 0 to 27 with an average of 2.97 for learners at Sapler schools and 2.48 for learners at other schools. The differences between Sapler and other schools was not statistically significant.

  2-Tailed

t

Test

p-level

Other

N1

Sapler

N2

Other

mean

Sapler

mean

This year partners

 

-.904

11.296

.367

.196

155

170

103

110

7.632

2.476

9.000

2.973

  Other

St. Dev.

Sapler

St. Dev.

 
This year partners

 

12.360

2.872

11.172

3.492

Recommendations:
  • Sapler should develop specific strategies for dealing with the issue of boys’ endorsement of male promiscuity.
  • Sapler should develop specific strategies for dealing with the disjunction between many learners’ professed opposition to promiscuity and their actual promiscuous behaviour.