WB00825_.GIF (134 bytes) Abstention

Abstention is the most reliable way of avoiding HIV/AIDS. Only approximately 20% of learners at Sapler schools and approximately 26% of learners at other schools thought it was acceptable for schoolboys and schoolgirls to have sex.

It's OK for a schoolboy to have sex
N=392 Other Sapler
Strongly 5.9 5.8
Agree 22 14
Not sure 25 28
Disagree 28 20
Strongly 19 33
chisq=14.; df=4; p=.008
It's OK for a schoolgirl to have sex
N=391 Other Sapler
Strongly 4.7 5.8
Agree 21 14
Not sure 27 28
Disagree 27 22
Strongly 21 30
chisq=7.; df=4; p=132

However, a much larger number reported that in fact they engaged in sexual activity. Learners were given the opportunity at several different points in the questionnaire to indicate if they have sex and there was some inconsistency in their responses, but typically only around a third of learners at any point indicated that they abstained from sex. 

There was a consistently larger proportion of learners at Sapler schools who indicated that they abstained. An attempt was made to reconcile the various figures, resulting in the following proportions of learners who engage in or abstain from sex.

N=411 Other Sapler
Have sex 76 72
Abstain 24 28
chisq=.842; df=1; p=.359

Of those who engage in sex, almost half report that they have stopped having sex, but it must be assumed that this question was taken to mean not that they now completely abstain but that at some point they did.

Have you stopped having sex?
N=270 Other Sapler
Yes 49 40
No 51 60
chisq=1.98; df=1; p=.159

It is sometimes argued that masturbation provides a safe sexual outlet and can thus help learners to abstain from other forms of sexual activity. 

However, there is clearly a considerable amount of uncertainty among learners about the effects of masturbation, with only 47% of learners at Sapler schools and 44% at other schools being certain that masturbation will not lead to madness.

Can masturbation (skomola) make you mad?
N=427 Other Sapler
Yes 16 17
No 44 47
Don't know 41 36
chisq=.9904; df=2; p=.610

Interestingly, when boys (who masturbate more frequently than girls do) are taken separately even more confusion is evident about the effects of masturbation, with up to 21% at non-Sapler schools believing that it can cause madness.

Can masturbation (skomola) make you mad?
Boys N=162 Other Sapler
Yes 21 19
No 47 43
Don't know 32 38
chisq=.4926; df=2; p=.782

Given this lack of knowledge, it is not surprising that only 42% of learners at Sapler schools and 39% of learners at other schools agreed or strongly agreed that it is acceptable for boys to masturbate.

It is OK if boys masturbate (skomola) sometimes
N=389 Other Sapler
Strongly 14 17
Disagree 7.3 5.8
Not sure 41 35
Agree 27 23
Strongly 12 19
chisq=6.; df=4; p=.214
Recommendations:
  • Sapler should continue to promote abstention as the best form of safe sex while accepting that most learners in the higher grades do engage in sexual activity with others.
  • Sapler should specifically inform learners that masturbation is a safe sex practice.